Discussion about this post

User's avatar
PHT's avatar

Sure, but how do you compare the impact of millions of people (and animal) eating corn (or drinking corn syrup, or using corn in any kind of process...) with the impact of people using data centers ?

Very intuitively, it feels like if I offer the choice of shutting down all data centers, and burning all corn fields, the impact would be dramatically different. I'm really curious how an economist would estimate each effect, and how they would put the two numbers in perspective, but just putting the numbers next to each other feels like doing only half of the job at best. (If an Oracle salesperson was doing it, we would call it downright dishonest.)

But I'm struggling with the fact that I could not objectivize my concern either - and again, I do not claim your figured are wrong.

PHT's avatar

Sorry if it is addressed in the main article, but to use the "corn water usage vs AI water usage" as a hook is a bit disingenuous - the metric itself completely ignores the vast difference in usage, value created, etc... Maybe you should compare "water used" over "number of buyers" / "number of consumers" etc... Or even, if you really want to use cold numbers, give me the share of GDP that derives from "corn has grown" vs "AI data center have churned numbers" - and give me the water intensity of both. I'm ready to bet that corn will suddenly look better .

(I suspect this "trick" must have a name - it's not really "cherry picking", and the data is probably perfectly legit, but it's not apple vs orange per se...

But it's the similar tocomparing carbon emission from cars (used by billions) and private jets (used by a few thousands) . Although, here, you can clear the conversation by having a single "per Capita" intensity. For corn vs AI, the right denominator is much less obvious - and there is a "value" element to it (maybe we could find a number like "what would it cost the economy if the corn / ai disappeared tomorrow" ? So of a "counterfactual intensity ?" Probably studied to death, but I don't know the word to lookup...)

2 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?